Rory's Cookie Monster Madness (Cookies & Cream Cashew Butter)

Rory's Cookie Monster Madness (Cookies & Cream Cashew Butter)

$16.49 USD

Sale

By	FIt Butters

Cookies and Cream Cashew Butter, called Rory’s Cookie Monster Madness, is literally like eating a bowl of cookies & cream ice cream, without the sugars and unhealthy fats, but in a jar of protein nut butter.

REFRIGERATION NOT REQUIRED

Instock

FIND IN STORE

Flavors may vary by store.

COOKIES & CREAM PROTEIN NUT BUTTER!

We buy all of the cashews we use directly from the farm and then dry-roast them, not fry them in oil. This makes for a higher quality protein nut butter and better tasting too!

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Why aren’t there as many toppings?

The Treat Without The Cheat!

Because this isn’t candy in a jar.

We add real OREOs to complement the cookies and cream flavor — not bury it under a layer of sugar. Every topping is intentional. Every ingredient earns its place.

We’re not here to win a sugar-stacking contest. We’re here to make something you can eat daily and feel good about.

The macros look like regular peanut butter…

Better Ingredients. Better Experience.

On paper? Maybe similar.

In reality? Completely different.

Here’s what makes Fit Butters deeper than macros:

Premium dry roasted nuts (baked, never fried)
Added protein to create a more complete protein source (and add flavor!)
Healthy fats from coconut oil - not a vegetable or seed oil
Real mix-ins in every jar
Small-batch crafted flavor development

Regular peanut butter is basic fuel. This is performance fuel with personality.

The benefits aren’t just in the numbers — they’re in the ingredient quality, the digestibility, and the flavor experience.

It’s not as sweet as other brands…

Low Sugar. BIG FLAVOR.

Correct.

We keep sugar intentionally low because this is a better-for-you spread with indulgent flavors, not an ultra-sweet dessert dip.

Our goal isn’t a sugar rush. It’s rich, nostalgic cookies and cream flavor — powered by premium dry roasted cashews, real ingredients, and balanced sweetness.

Indulgent in flavor. Disciplined in formulation.

Treat yourself — without cheating yourself.

Who Is It For?

Mission-Driven Flavor Lovers

✔ The lifter who still wants dessert

✔ The macro tracker who refuses to eat boring food

✔ The busy parent who wants a smarter sweet option

✔ The athlete who wants more than plain nut butter

This isn’t for someone looking for frosting in a jar. This is for someone building something — muscle, discipline, momentum.

How Do I Eat It?

Versatile Craving Crusher!

Straight from the spoon
Swirled into oatmeal
On protein pancakes
Blended into smoothies
On apples, toast, or rice cakes

Once you try it, plain nut butter won’t hit the same.

TOPPED WITH REAL OREOS!

Generic just won't cut it. We went all in by using authentic Oreos in our FIt Butters Rory's Cookie Monster Madness protein nut butter. Each jar is hand topped with REAL Oreo pieces...mix them in and enjoy!

Don't worry, if you don't see them as soon as you open the lid, know that they are in there and they probably sunk into the butter. A quick stir of a spoon and BOOM, you should see them!

Chocolate chips can melt depending on the climate.

MADE WITH WHEY PROTEIN!

Each jar of Fit Butters Rory's Cookie Monster Madness cookies and cream protein nut butter is made with a high-quality whey protein. We don't just use any whey protein, we use a cookies and cream flavored whey protein to flavor the entire base of the protein nut butter.

COCONUT OIL FOR HEALTHY FATS AND MCTS!

Unlike most nut butters on the market today, we do not "roast" (might as well call it fry) our nuts in an oil. We stay away from inflammatory oils like seed oils, or oils that your French fries may have been deep fried in. We only use high-quality coconut oil.

Coconut oil is a natural source of MCTs which are easier for the body to digest. MCTs are also known to stimulate fat burning, thyroid function and energy production. Less oil separation too!